|
|
Home : Travel to Africa :
Review:Lonely Planet West Africa
Travel to Africa
Travel-helper.com review all the media and related products you need to make your travel to Africa more than perfect. Check out "Lonely Planet West Africa" below.
Lonely Planet West Africa
Format: Paperback
Author: Anthony Ham
ReleaseDate: October, 2006
Publisher: Lonely Planet Publications
Rating:
Decent info, but presented awkwardly. 
Firstly, it is not geared to someone making a comprehensive West Africa trip but rather reads like a collection of individual country guides. This is an adequate guide, but was disappointing in a few areas. It's OK if you are going to just fly in a hang out in a single country, but planning cross border itineraries is a chore. There could be better integration for the area.
Secondly, using the maps and references to them is a bit taxing. Place names that would likely be obsure to the reader are presented in the text without specifying country or area; the only way to figure out where or how is to scan maps randomly for some idea of specifically where they are talking about. Place names are often referred to with different spellings, or more colloquially, in the text than on the maps, making finding them once again a tiring guessing game. There is a lack of consistency. Beyond that, the maps are small and lacking in detail. In other words, you can sort it all out, but this guide makes you work harder than you should have to. You get the feeling that it needed to be proofed once more.
I agree with the accusations of ethnocentrism mentioned previously, but I've grown used to it in LP guides, and in a way appreciate seeing the author's predjudices up front.
Use this guide and you'll have a fine trip, I think, but you'll spend too many hours wrestling logistic details from the text when you could be perusing the fun stuff.
I use LP, Rough Guide, and Moon guides alternately when I travel. Actually, I usually buy all three, study them all before departure, and take the one I think is most useful. I have not found any one brand to be consistently better or worse, it varies by area and author. In this case I think the Rough Guide is much better. It very neatly addresses all my reservations above, and with a better layout.
From a returned Peace Corps Volunteer 
Africa travel. This book is practically the bible for W. I lived and worked in W. Africa for 3 years (2 years as a Peace Corps volunteer) and I never went anywhere without consulting LP. The information is as accurate as anything out there. It offers you suggested itineraries and "off the beaten path" suggestions as well as the traditionally touristy destinations. Many parts are less objective than other parts and the writers tend to harp on corruption. But W. Africa is a pretty corrupt place in general. If you don't like the editorial sections, skip 'em, the info you need is still there.
SMEARED BY DEROGATORY PHRASES 
I also appreciated its details on several tourists' trails, accomodations, means of transportation, and so on. Indeed, this book ("Lonely Planet West Africa") did a good job in outlining many of the popular tourist attractions that are located in this Sub-Saharan region of Africa. However, I was very disappointed to note that (just like the "Lonely Planet Africa on a Shoestring") this book is full of discouraging comments. Some of the phrases Lonely Planet used in this book are quite offensive. For sure, most foreigners who travel to (West) African countries are not expecting to see a paradise, but that does not mean that there is no better way of presenting real and imaginary negative thoughts. This book is smeared by terms and phrases, which I consider derogatory to both (West) Africa and (West) Africans. As a result of this, I will never recommend it to anyone until there is a change of heart by Lonely Planet in subsequent editions.
Related products:
click image or link for details on these Africa travel books.
|
|
|
|
Navigation:
|
|
Travel-helper.com: Main index, About us, Link to us
Pick your continent:
Africa,
Asia,
Australia,
Canada,
Caribbean,
Europe,
Latin America,
Middle East,
Polar Regions,
United States
Regions and countries in Africa
-Algeria
-Botswana
-Burkina Faso
-Coastal west Africa
-Democratic Republic of Congo
-Egypt
-Eritrea
-Ethiopia and Djibouti
-Gambia and Senegal
-Kenya
-Lesotho
-Libya
-Madagascar and Comoros
-Mozambique
-Namibia
-Malavi
-Morocco
-Niger and Nigeria
-Rwanda and Uganda
-Seychelles
-Soa Tome and Principe
-Somalia
-South Africa
-Sudan
-Swaziland
-Tanzania
-Tunisia
-Western Africa
-Zambia
-Zimbabwe
|
|
|
|